The sprint goes on trial. The prosecution presents what held us back, the defense what worked, and the jury decides what gets fixed and what we keep. Here we judge the sprint, never the people.
5 to 10 people (8 is ideal)
About 60 minutes
One shared screen
Hand out the roles and share each person the link to their card, or print the guide: each role gets its own page.
How to hand out the roles
There’s always one judge. The prosecution and the defense get the same number of people, and everyone else is on the jury. An odd-numbered jury is best: on a tie, the evidence is dismissed.
People
Judge
Prosecution
Defense
Jury
5
1
1
1
2
6
1
1
1
3
8
1
2
2
3
10
1
2
2
5
In the app, Shuffle roles assigns them at random using the 8-person split; then you can adjust them by hand.
The phases at a glance
Phase
Time
Who speaks
What happens
Room
5 min
Facilitator
Roles are assigned and the previous sentence is written down.
Opening
2 min
Judge
Reads the opening and checks whether the previous sentence was carried out.
Evidence
5 min
Prosecution and Defense
They write charges (what held us back) and merits (what worked).
Prosecution
4 min
Prosecution
Presents each charge and its impact.
Defense
4 min
Defense
Presents each merit and why to keep it.
Rebuttals
1 min per side
Prosecution, then Defense
Each side responds to the other.
Jury
3 min
Jury
Votes on each piece of evidence: upholds or dismisses.
Sentencing
10 min
Judge and the whole team
Verdict, actions with owners, and the record.
Judge
One person. Can be the Scrum Master.
Your mission: run the trial, give people the floor, keep time and respect, and read the sentence.
Opening 2 min
Read out loud the script that appears on screen. It starts like this:
The Sprint Court is now in session. Appearing before the court is the sprint, charged with not being the perfect sprint. Here we judge the sprint, never the people.
Then ask about each action from the previous sentence: “Was it carried out?”, and mark it done or pending.
Evidence 5 min
Prosecution and Defense, you have five minutes to file your evidence. One idea per piece of evidence, with concrete facts.
Arguments and rebuttals 9 min
The prosecution has the floor.
The defense has the floor.
Prosecution’s rebuttal: one minute. Now the defense: one minute.
Use Order in the court (the gavel) if people talk out of turn. If someone points at a person instead of the sprint, call Objection! and redirect: “Objection sustained: let’s talk about what happened in the process.”
Jury 3 min
Members of the jury: vote on each piece of evidence. Uphold the charges we need to fix and the merits worth keeping.
Sentencing 10 min
This court finds the sprint [Guilty / Acquitted / Tied], with [n] charges upheld and [m] merits recognized. The team is sentenced to carry out these improvement actions…
Read each upheld charge and ask the team for a concrete action and an owner. Close with:
Court is adjourned. We’ll review this sentence at the next trial.
Your tone sets the mood: solemn but fun. The goal is to improve the next sprint, not to win the trial.
Prosecution
1 or 2 people.
Your mission: prove with facts what held the sprint back, so the team can fix it.
Evidence 5 min
File the charges: one per idea, with a concrete fact. Types: Blocker, Delay, Bug, Communication, Scope, or Other.
Good: “The QA environment was down for two days and stalled regression testing.”
Avoid: “QA is always late.” It’s an opinion and it points at people.
Prosecution’s argument 4 min
Present each charge and press Show so it appears in the courtroom.
Your Honor, members of the jury: the prosecution presents Charge 1, type [Blocker]. [Concrete fact]. This affected the sprint because [impact: time, quality, delivery].
Rebuttal 1 min
With respect to the defense: [merit] is true, but it doesn’t make up for [charge], which cost us [impact].
Sentencing
For each upheld charge, propose a concrete action: “Check the QA environment on the first day of the sprint.”
You’re charging the sprint, not your teammates. A good charge describes what happened and what it cost.
Defense
1 or 2 people.
Your mission: show what worked in the sprint, so the team keeps it.
Evidence 5 min
File the merits: one per idea, with a concrete fact. Types: Delivery, Quality, Improvement, Collaboration, Learning, or Other.
Good: “Zero incidents in production after the deployment.”
Avoid: “We worked really hard.” It’s hard to verify.
Defense’s argument 4 min
Present each merit and press Show so it appears in the courtroom.
Your Honor, members of the jury: the defense presents Merit 1, type [Quality]. [Concrete fact]. It’s worth keeping because [benefit].
Rebuttal 1 min
The prosecution is right that [charge], but the sprint also achieved [merit], and that shows [conclusion].
Sentencing
Recognized merits go under What we keep: remind the team to keep doing them.
Defending isn’t denying the problems: it’s making sure the good doesn’t get lost while fixing the bad.
Jury
The rest of the team (an odd number is best).
Your mission: listen to both sides and decide what gets fixed and what we keep.
During the arguments
Listen and take notes. You can ask the judge to have the prosecution or the defense clarify a point.
Deliberation 3 min
Vote on each piece of evidence by tapping your name: upholds, dismisses, or no vote. To decide, ask yourself:
Charges: is it a fact? Did it really affect the sprint? Can we do something about it?
Merits: is it a fact? Is it worth continuing to do?
I vote to uphold this charge because [reason].
Sentencing
Help turn each upheld charge into an action the team can carry out and check at the next retro.
An upheld charge becomes an improvement action; an upheld merit is something the team keeps. On a tie, the evidence is dismissed.
Facilitator
Whoever runs the screen. Usually the Scrum Master, and it can also be the judge.
Your mission: set up the courtroom, share the screen, and keep the app in step with the trial.
Before the meeting
Open the Trial and share your screen in the meeting.
In Room, enter the sprint, the names and roles (or press Shuffle roles), and the previous sentence: the actions from the last retro, one per line.
Share this guide with each person: the link to their card.
During the trial
Move between phases with Next and start the timer when the judge gives someone the floor.
In Evidence, type what the prosecution and the defense dictate (or hand them the keyboard).
During the arguments, press Show on the evidence being presented.
In Jury, record each person’s vote by tapping their name.
When it’s over
Fill in the action and owner for each sentence, and press Copy record to save it. The data stays only in this browser. New trial starts another one with these sentences as the previous sentence.
Drag the courtroom to turn the camera, or leave Auto camera on, which focuses on whoever has the floor.
Golden rules
We judge the sprint, never the people.
Each piece of evidence is a concrete fact, not an opinion.
Everyone respects the turns and times the judge sets.